2009 - Best Album of the Year: Steel Panther - Feel the Steel
- Most Disappointing Album of the Year: Chickenfoot - Chickenfoot
- The Lifeson Award: Steven Tyler
- DVD of the Year (tie): Iron Maiden - Flight 666, and The Story of Anvil
- Release of the Year: Iron Maiden - Flight 666 (2DVD set)
|  |  The Mindcrime II (awarded for purposely pursuing terrible ideas to inevitably disasterous conclusions): 2009 winner: Lita Ford - Wicked Wonderland.  The Screaming Devil Baby (awarded to an artist for pathetic behavior). 2009 winner: Steven Tyler |
2008 - Best Album of the Year: Whitesnake - Good to be Bad
- Most Disappointing Album of the Year: Judas Priest - Nostradamus
- The Lifeson Award: The Scorpions
- DVD of the Year: Iron Maiden - Live After Death
- Release of the Year: Iron Maiden - Live After Death
|  |  The Mindcrime II (awarded for purposely pursuing terrible ideas to inevitably disasterous conclusions): 2008 winner: Judas Priest - Nostradamus  The Screaming Devil Baby (awarded to an artist for pathetic behavior). 2008 winner: Scott Weiland |
2007 - Best Album of the Year: Rush - Snakes & Arrows
- Most Disappointing Album of the Year: Ozzy Osbourne - Black Rain
- The Lifeson Award: Gary Moore
- DVD of the Year: Heaven and Hell - Live at Radio City
- Release of the Year: Heaven and Hell - Live at Radio City DVD
|  |  The Mindcrime II (awarded for purposely pursuing terrible ideas to inevitably disasterous conclusions): 2007 winner: Queensryche  The Screaming Devil Baby (awarded to an artist for pathetic behavior). 2007 winner: Michael Schenker |
2006 - Best Album of the Year: Iron Maiden - A Matter of Life and Death
- Most Disappointing Album of the Year: Queensryche - Operation Mindcrime II
- The "Lifeson" Award: (unclaimed)
- DVD of the Year: Whitesnake - Live In The Shadow Of The Blues
- Release of the Year: Whitesnake - Live In The Shadow Of The Blues
|  | New Awards for 2006!  The Mindcrime II (awarded for purposely pursuing terrible ideas to inevitably disasterous conclusions): 2006 winner: Queensryche  The Screaming Devil Baby (awarded to an artist for pathetic behavior). 2006 winner: Michael Schenker |
2005 - Best Album of the Year: (tie) Tony Iommi & Glenn Hughes - Fused, Bruce Dickinson - Tyranny of Souls
- Most Disappointing Album of the Year: Black Label Society - Mafia
- The "Lifeson" Award: Vivian Campbell
- DVD of the Year: Rush - R30
- Release of the Year: (tie) Aerosmith - Rocking The Joint Dual Disc, Eric Johnson - Bloom CD
|  |  |
2004 - Best Album of the Year: Tony Iommi & Glenn Hughes - The DEP Sessions
- Most Disappointing Album of the Year: Aerosmith - Honkin on Bobo
- The "Lifeson" Award: Van Halen
- DVD of the Year: Iron Maiden - The Early Years
- Release of the Year: Tony Iommi & Glenn Hughes - The DEP Sessions and Iron Maiden -The Early Years DVD
|  | |
2003 - Best Album of the Year: Gary Moore - Live at the Monsters of Rock and Anthrax - We've Come for you All
- Most Disappointing Album of the Year: Metallica - St. Anger
- The "Lifeson" Award: Metallica
- DVD of the Year: Led Zeppelin 2 DVD set
- Release of the Year: Led Zeppelin 2 DVD set
|  |  |
2002 - Best Album of the Year: Gary Moore - Scars
- Most Disappointing Album of the Year: Rush - Vapor Trails
- The "Lifeson" Award: Van Halen
|  | |
2001 - Best Album of the Year: Halford - Live Insurrection
- Most Disappointing Album of the Year: Aerosmith - Just Push Play
- The "Lifeson" Award: Aerosmith
|  | |
| |
| Retroactively voted Dino Album of the Year Awards |
| |
2000: (Tie) - Halford - Resurrection
- Iron Maiden - Brave New World
|  |  |
| 1999: John Norum - Slipped into Tomorrow |  | |
| 1998: Bruce Dickinson - The Chemical Wedding |  | |
| 1997: Led Zeppelin - BBC Sessions |  | |
1996: (Tie) - John Norum - Worlds Away
- ZZ Top - Rhythmeen
|  |  |
| 1995: Van Halen - Balance |  | |
| 1994: Pride & Glory - Pride & Glory |  | |
| 1993: Savatage - Edge Of Thorns |  | |
1992: (Tie) - Megadeth - Countdown to Extinction
- Alice in Chains - Dirt
|  |  |
| 1991: Ozzy Osbourne - No More Tears |  | |
| 1990: Judas Priest - Painkiller |  | |
1989: (3 way tie) - Badlands - Badlands
- Blue Murder - Blue Murder
- Aerosmith - Pump
|   
| |
| 1988: Queensryche - Operation Mindcrime |  | |
| 1987: Guns & Roses - Appetite for Destruction |  | |
| 1986: David Lee Roth - Eat 'Em and Smile |  | |
| 1985: Iron Maiden - Live After Death |  | |
| 1984: Van Halen - 1984 |  | |
| 1983: Iron Maiden - Piece of Mind |  | |
| 1982: Iron Maiden - The Number Of The Beast |  | |
| 1981: Rush - Moving Pictures |  | |
| 1980: Ozzy Osbourne - Blizzard Of Ozz |  | |
| 1979: AC/DC - Highway To Hell |  | |
| 1978: Van Halen - Van Halen |  | |
| 1977: AC/DC - Let There Be Rock |  | |
| 1976: Rainbow - Rising |  | |
| 1975: Led Zeppelin - Physical Graffiti |  | |
| 1974: Deep Purple - Burn |  | |
| 1973: Led Zeppelin - Houses of the Holy |  | |
| 1972: Deep Purple - Machine Head |  | |
| 1971: Led Zeppelin - IV |  | |
| 1970: Deep Purple - In Rock |  | |
| 1969: Led Zeppelin - Led Zeppelin II |  | |
| 1968: Jeff Beck Group - Truth |  | |
| 1967: Jim Hendrix Experience - Are You Experienced |  | |
| 1966: Cream - Fresh Cream |  | |